As Henry lays down bales in the barn for people to sit on during the vigil, he and Barbara argue. Henry never wanted the vigil since it seems too close to a memorial service. However, Barbara feels the vigil is the exact opposite; it shows that the community continues to hope for Anna’s survival. After Barbara leaves, Henry reflects their fight was not about the vigil: Their marriage has been in trouble for a long time, with them sleeping in separate bedrooms.

At the house, Jenny tells Barbara about the row between the friends before Sarah’s overdose. Barbara assures Jenny that Sarah’s overdose is not her fault. Once Sarah feels better, Jenny can explain her side of things to her friend. The vicar, who organized the vigil, drops in. He and the Ballards watch lights from candles and lamps grow as people walk toward the house. Even Henry cannot help being moved at the sight. Henry decides he will soon tell everyone the truth.

Matthew and Melanie meet at a coffee shop to discuss the Anna Ballard case. Matthew shows Melanie the postcards Ella has been receiving. Melanie promises to examine the plastic-wrapped postcard for prints. She tells Matthew that the lead investigator on the Anna Ballard case—a DI (detective inspector) from London who is never named in the text—will not be happy with Matthew’s meddling.